You can’t see your own system from the inside

You can’t see your own system from the inside

Ask a head of fundraising what’s holding her team back and you’ll get a clear, confident answer. Ask her chief executive and you’ll get a different one, just as confident. Ask the newest fundraiser, six months in, and you’ll get a third that neither of the others would have thought of.

I’ve stopped treating any of those answers as wrong. Each person is describing the part of the system they can see from where they sit, and the trouble starts when one of those views gets taken for the whole picture. If you’re trying to work out what’s holding your own fundraising back right now, that’s the first thing I’d keep in mind.

Blind spots come with the territory

No organisation can see its own blind spots from the inside. That’s simply what a blind spot is, and it isn’t a criticism of anyone.

The head of fundraising sees the sign-off process that takes six weeks, because she lives with it. She may not see that her team’s plans reach finance as a surprise every October. The chief executive sees the income line that keeps wobbling and the board that keeps asking about it. They may not know the team has rebuilt the same appeal plan from scratch every year for five years. The new fundraiser spots all the workarounds everyone else stopped noticing in about their third month.

When I wrote about the quiet crisis in fundraising last December, one thing I kept hearing was people saying they knew something was wrong but couldn’t put their finger on it, and I hear it more now than I did then. Good fundraisers can feel that something’s off, but they can’t see the whole shape from where they stand, and the pieces they can see don’t add up to an explanation.

Why the audit says so up front

When we put the Fundraising System Audit online, I had it say something at the start that I suspect most diagnostic tools would rather keep quiet about. If one person answers it, you get one person’s view, with that person’s blind spots.

I also built it to flag every score where the evidence is thin, and to cap those scores so they can’t look healthier than the evidence allows. If you tell it your stewardship is excellent but can’t point to anything that shows it, the report will say so, politely.

Both of those choices make the report a little less flattering, and I think a lot more useful.

For the same reason, a person at Fundraiser In The Room reads every report before it goes back. It would have been quicker and cheaper to let the tool score it and send it straight out. I didn’t, because I’ve watched a fundraising director reading her organisation’s scores for the first time. One badly judged sentence in that report could cost her a lot with her chief executive, and I’m not willing to leave that to chance. It makes the whole thing slower, and I’ve made my peace with that.

Where the work is

When a result in a diagnostic feels wrong to you, talk it through with a colleague before you decide what to make of it. The places where two people in the same organisation see things differently are very often where the real work is.

If the head of fundraising thinks decision-making is fine and the finance director thinks it’s a mess, that gap is a finding in its own right. Two people are living inside the same system and experiencing it in completely different ways, and my guess would be that something between them isn’t working.

It’s also why I’m wary of diagnosing a fundraising problem by asking fundraising alone. A lot of what holds fundraising back sits in finance, programmes or governance, or in how the whole organisation makes decisions, and it usually takes someone from outside the team to spot it.

Ask why more than once

Earlier this year I wrote about why so much organisational change fails quietly, and the first thing I suggested was being honest about what you’re really trying to change. “We need to raise more money” is a symptom, and the useful question is what sits underneath it.

The simplest tool I know for getting there is the 5 Whys. The first answer to “why” is usually the one that’s easiest to say in a meeting, and if you keep asking you get closer to the reason that actually needs fixing. It works much better with two people from different parts of the organisation than with one. There’s a free 5 Whys toolkit on the site if you’d like a structure for it.

Try it with someone from finance

Whatever diagnostic you use, ours or anyone else’s, I wouldn’t do it alone. Sit down with a colleague from outside fundraising. Finance would be my first choice, because they see the system from the other end and they’ll ask the questions you’ve stopped asking.

The free Fundraising System Stress Test is a good place to start, and it takes about two minutes. Take it separately, then compare your answers over a coffee and begin with the questions where you disagree.

Take the free Stress Test


More insights

See your own system

Two minutes, sixteen questions. The free Stress Test shows where your fundraising system is under the most strain.