Why audience-led fundraising stalls inside the organisation

You may be in a planning meeting right now, or just out of one. Everyone agreed that fundraising should start with the people who give. Heads nodded, and someone said the word "audience" a few times. Come the next review though and the plan on the table is still organised by appeal calendar and by team.
Nobody in that room was being difficult, and the intention was real.
What's worth knowing though is that when the plan looks the same as last year's, the reason usually sits in how the organisation is built. It is worth understanding that before anyone is blamed, including yourself.
Nobody owns the supporter
Ask yourself who looks after one supporter's relationship with your charity over the whole time she gives and the honest answer is often that nobody does. Regular giving looks after the direct debit, and major gifts looks after the conversation about a larger gift. Legacies has the will, while community has the sponsored challenge participation (and sometimes the volunteering). Each team does sensible work for its own target. Hand-offs between them tend to depend on goodwill and on who happens to know each other within the team.
The supporter is one person. She gave to an appeal, started a monthly gift, ran a 10k for a friend, and may one day leave a gift in her will. To her that is a single relationship. Inside the charity it is held in several places, each with its own data, and nobody's job covers the whole of it.
An audience-led plan needs someone to hold the whole relationship, and most structures were built to hold the parts. If you are sketching next year's plan now, this is a fair place to start looking.
Targets pull the other way
Most income targets are set by stream. That suits budgeting, and it quietly penalises the behaviour an audience-led approach asks for.
Suppose a regular giver would be better served, and would give more over time, if she were introduced to the major gifts team. For the team that holds her now, passing her on looks like a loss against its own number. For the team that receives her, it looks like a gain it did not earn. Anyone who has argued over credit for a gift knows how fast the talk turns to the target. So the introduction often never happens. The fundraisers involved are behaving sensibly inside the system they were given, and many would make the introduction if the numbers allowed it. Asking people to put the supporter first has little effect while they are still measured on the stream.
The board sees streams too
Boards usually receive reporting that mirrors the structure, with income by stream, against budget and against last year. It is accurate and easy to read. It leaves out what an audience-led approach would want to show, which is what happens to supporters as they move through the organisation over time.
Trustees can only steer by what they are shown. If the pack is built by stream, their questions will follow the streams, and the team that prepares it will answer the questions it is asked. A board that never sees this has no reason to ask for it, and when nobody asks, nobody builds it. The reporting stays as it was, and the plan stays organised around the reporting.
Where to begin
A new strategy document is rarely the best first step. A few plain questions, asked honestly in the room where the plan is being made, will tell you more.
Who is accountable today for a supporter's whole relationship, and what can that person actually decide? Think about the points where a supporter is handed from one team to another, and what happens to each team's numbers when it occurs. And if trustees asked whether supporters are better off than last year, what could you show them?
The answers tend to show where the system was designed around something other than the audience. Finding those places is a design task, and people who are already stretched can do it without adding to their workload.
We built the Fundraising System Audit to look at how the whole fundraising system fits together.
If you would like to talk any of this through, we are glad to have a conversation.
Where does a supporter get passed between teams at your charity, and who notices?