What the cost-to-income ratio can't tell you

It's budget season, and somewhere a fundraising director is getting ready to ask for more. She has the figures to hand: income by stream, cost by stream, and the ratio the board likes to see. She'll still be asked the one question none of it answers. If we give you this money, what will it bring back, and when?
Nobody in that meeting is being unreasonable.
The finance director is right to ask, and the fundraising director is right to want the investment. The trouble, though, is that the numbers on the table were built to answer a different question.
What the ratio measures
The cost-to-income ratio looks backwards. It tells you what last year's income cost to raise, which is useful for spotting waste and for comparing one year with the next.
It says nothing about what this year's spend will produce. Money spent finding new monthly givers can take years to pay back, and then keeps paying for a long time after. An appeal can bring its money back within weeks and then stop. On the ratio, the first can look worse than the second for years, even when it's the better investment.
So a charity that manages its fundraising by the ratio drifts towards the money that comes back quickly. Over time that can starve the work that builds income for later, without anyone ever deciding to.
Why nobody owns the return
Ask around your organisation who's responsible for the return on fundraising investment and you'll often get two answers that don't meet.
Fundraising owns the activity and finance owns the accounts, and the return sits somewhere in between. Working it out needs fundraising's knowledge of how supporters behave over time and finance's discipline about cash, timing and risk. Most charities have nowhere those two meet, so each side brings its own numbers and the budget conversation turns into a negotiation.
It's tiring for both of them, and it often ends in a compromise neither of them wanted, usually a flat budget and a higher target.
The board rarely helps, though it doesn't mean to. Trustees are usually shown income against budget and the ratio against last year. Those are the numbers they ask about, so those are the numbers that get prepared. A director who wants to argue for work that pays back slowly has to make the case outside the papers the board actually reads.
What a better conversation looks like
When this goes well, fundraising and finance build the case together, before the budget round rather than during it. They agree a small set of assumptions: how many supporters stay, for how long, and what they give over that time. They're honest about when the money comes in, so the board isn't promised in year one a return that only arrives in year three. And they treat fundraising as a set of investments with different time horizons, which is how the same organisation already treats its reserves.
That changes what trustees see as well. Next to this year's income, they get a plain view of what each part of the fundraising is expected to bring back and over what period. It gives them something to steer by, and a fairer way to ask whether the money is working than watching a ratio go up or down.
All it takes is the two people who each hold half the picture sitting down with the same spreadsheet.
Where to begin
Before your next budget meeting, take these questions to your finance lead.
Which parts of our fundraising pay back within a year, and which take longer? What would we expect each of them to bring back over five years, and how sure are we? If the board asked tomorrow what next year's investment will return, what could we show them?
If those are hard to answer, you're not alone, and it usually says more about how the system is set up than about how hard anyone is working.
We built the Fundraising System Audit to look at how the whole fundraising system fits together, including how investment decisions get made.
When did your fundraising and finance leads last work out the return together?