Three missed targets, three different explanations

Three missed targets, three different explanations

It’s November. In most charities that means the reforecast is done, next year’s budget is half built, and someone is about to ask the fundraising director why this year came in short.

You’ll be expected to answer about people, and the answers might well be true. The spring appeal underperformed. The new corporate lead hasn’t come good yet. You lost a strong major gifts manager in March and it took four months to replace her.

The question I’d ask, though, and one I’d quite like boards to ask too, is what you said last year.

If I sat down with most fundraising directors and lined up their last three years of explanations side by side, I’d expect three different stories. A staffing gap one year, a disappointing appeal the next, a big trust that didn’t renew the year after that. Each one would sound reasonable at the time, and each would be about a particular person or a particular bit of bad luck, even though the result itself came out the same every year.

When the result outlives the people

There’s an old line from systems thinking that every system is perfectly designed to get the results it gets. I used to find that a bit glib, and over the years I’ve come round to it.

When a result keeps repeating after the people have changed, I stop looking at the people and look at how the place is set up. How targets get set, for a start. In a lot of charities next year’s number is last year’s number plus whatever the organisation needs, and nobody checks whether the fundraising system can actually produce it. Then there’s how income lines compete for the same small pot of investment, so the one with the loudest head of department tends to win. And there’s the work that falls between two teams, which in my experience usually belongs to nobody.

None of this ends up in the board paper as a reason. It’s too dull and too structural, and frankly too awkward, because it points at decisions made well above the fundraising team. So the explanation drifts back to people, because people are visible and you can name them.

The forecast that’s always on track

Back in August I wrote about forecasts as theatre. The number gets agreed months in advance, so every meeting after that turns into a defence of it. Fundraisers end up bringing a version of reality shaped for the room, one that’s hopeful enough to avoid a hard conversation and has enough caveats in it to survive being wrong.

Missed targets work in much the same way. If your forecast has said “on track” for three years and the year-end has surprised you three times, I’d stop working on the spreadsheet. By then the organisation has usually learned that honest forecasts lead to difficult meetings, so people stop giving them. When the miss finally arrives, the system needs somebody to own it, and that’s how you end up with three explanations for one problem.

None of this lets fundraisers off the hook, and sometimes the appeal really was weak. But you can’t tell which misses are about performance and which are about design until you look at the design, and a lot of organisations never get round to it.

What I’d take into the room

Before you defend this year’s numbers or set next year’s, write down the explanation you gave for each of the last three shortfalls, one line each. Then ask yourself which of those reasons would still hold if every person in your team were different. Any reason that would survive a complete change of staff is about the system, and that’s the part the board needs to hear.

Then pick the one structural thing you think sits underneath all three. You’ll probably know straight away. It might be how the target is set, or the fact that nothing gets investment unless it’s a campaign. Whatever it is, say it in the meeting, with three years of evidence behind it.

It’s a harder conversation to start than “we’ll do better next year”, but in my experience a lot of chief executives and chairs are glad to have it. They’ve often sensed the same pattern without having the words for it.

Start with a number

If you’d like something firmer than a hunch to take in with you, the Fundraising System Stress Test is free and takes about two minutes. Sixteen questions show which part of your fundraising system is under the most strain and where the pressure is coming from. You get your results straight away.

Take the free Stress Test

And if your last three misses came with three different explanations, which one would you put money on now?


More insights

See your own system

Two minutes, sixteen questions. The free Stress Test shows where your fundraising system is under the most strain.