The person your team can’t do without

The person your team can’t do without

Think of the person your fundraising team relies on most. You probably didn’t have to think for long.

Now imagine they ring in tomorrow and say they’ll be off for a month. They’re not leaving and nothing dramatic has happened. They’re just gone for four weeks. What stops?

I’ve started asking this in most of my conversations with fundraising directors, and the answers follow a pattern. The trust renewals stall, because only she knows which ones are due and what each funder likes to hear. Or the calls to the top fifty donors dry up, because they live in one person’s diary and nowhere else.

Nobody designed it that way. Someone good joined, was helpful, said yes a lot, and over three or four years the team quietly rebuilt itself around them. It works fine for as long as they’re in the building, which is exactly why nobody thinks to question it.

The finding I didn’t expect

When I started scoring fundraising systems properly, I assumed every charity would turn out to be weak somewhere different, and mostly that’s what has happened.

One area has been the exception. We’ve now run the Fundraising System Audit with 24 organisations of very different sizes and causes, and in all 24 the same Force came out below zero. I call it Capability Infrastructure. It covers the tools, templates, systems and written-down ways of working that let a team do the same good thing twice.

I’ve gone back and forth on why. One explanation is that it’s real and it’s sector-wide. Charities fund campaigns and they fund people, but hardly anyone funds what connects the two. There’s no budget line for “write down how we run the major donor pipeline so the next person doesn’t have to work it out again”. So each team rebuilds it every time someone leaves.

The other explanation is that it’s me, and the way I score this Force sets a bar most organisations can’t clear yet. I take that possibility seriously, and now the audit is online there’ll be a lot more evidence coming in, so if I’m wrong I’d rather find out. Having sat in a lot of these rooms, though, my guess is that it’s mostly the first.

What it looks like from the inside

Mostly it looks like a hard-working team, with one colleague everyone goes to who’s cheerful about it and quietly exhausted.

Sometimes it’s a database that gives the board pack exactly what it needs, provided you know which report to run and which filters to untick, and only one person does. Sometimes it’s a lovely stewardship rhythm that nobody else in the team could describe, because the whole thing lives in someone’s head.

In the summer I wrote a piece about donor relationships that don’t end so much as starve. One of the questions in it was who owns the stewardship rhythm. If it lives in one fundraiser’s diary and leaves when they do (and they do leave), you have a person rather than a system. I’d now say the same about almost everything a fundraising team does well.

The cost goes beyond inconvenience. Every time knowledge walks out of the door, the charity pays for the months it takes the next person to work it all out again, and for the income that slips while they do, and neither cost shows up in the accounts. What you might notice, eighteen months later, is that trust income dipped the year your trusts manager left, and everyone put it down to bad luck.

Something to try this week

Go back to the person you thought of at the start. Take ten minutes and write down, honestly, everything that would stop or go wrong if they were away for a month.

Then go through it line by line and ask whether each thing is written down somewhere another person could find it. Being able to ask around doesn’t count.

If the list is short, you’ve built something sturdier than most.

If it’s long, you’re in good company. Given what the audits show, I’d guess most of the 24 charities we’ve audited would end up with a long list too. Once it’s on paper you can plan the work and put a budget against it, and most of it isn’t expensive: a shared template, a process someone has recorded, an hour a month for someone to write down what they know. It’s dull work and it will never make the board pack. I think it’s also what decides whether a team that’s good this year is still good in three years.

It’s worth having the conversation with the person on your list, too. In my experience they’re usually relieved that someone has noticed.

If you want to see the whole picture

If the list has you wondering what else is quietly propping your team up, that’s what the Self Audit is for. Capability Infrastructure is one of the eight Forces the Fundraising System Audit looks at, and the Self Audit scores your own organisation on all eight, with the evidence behind each score. It shows you where your fundraising system is earning a return and where it’s losing value. Most people take 30 to 45 minutes over it, and it costs £495 plus VAT. A person at Fundraiser In The Room reads every report before it comes back to you.

Start the Self Audit

And if you’ve worked somewhere that really got this right, I’d like to hear what it looked like.


More insights

See your own system

Two minutes, sixteen questions. The free Stress Test shows where your fundraising system is under the most strain.