Give the finance director a page of their own

Give the finance director a page of their own

If you’re putting next year’s fundraising budget together this month, there’s a fair chance you’re tired. The reforecast is done, the year-end push is about to start, and somewhere in the middle of all that you’re being asked to pick next year’s numbers out of the air and then defend them, most likely to your finance director.

The story and the spreadsheet

Most fundraising budgets reach the finance director as a story. Usually it’s a good one with a proper plan behind it, whether that’s growing regular giving or hiring a legacy manager. Fundraisers are good at stories, and it’s a big part of the job.

The questions a finance director wants to ask have nowhere to go in a story, though. What will this return, when, and what happens if it doesn’t? What are we already spending that we can’t see? When those go unanswered the case is rarely turned down outright. More often it gets trimmed or deferred, or passed with a shrug and a look that says “we’ll see”.

I don’t think finance directors are the villains here. Most of the ones I’ve worked with want fundraising to grow, but they can’t sign off a budget on the strength of a feeling.

The money nobody can see

In my experience, the biggest cost in most fundraising operations isn’t in the budget at all.

Back in February I wrote about noise, by which I meant the meetings that produce updates and never a decision, the data nobody can turn into anything useful, and the processes that only exist because they always have. None of it sits in overheads or prompts an audit query, yet it soaks up donor money every day. Good fundraisers spend hours smoothing over delays and explaining decisions that were never theirs to make, and that’s time they aren’t spending on fundraising.

Finance directors can usually sense that cost even when they can’t measure it. So a request for more investment, on top of a system they suspect is already leaking, feels risky to them. They’d rather fix the bucket before they pour more into it, and I can’t really blame them.

Two findings from our audits

We’ve now run the Fundraising System Audit with 24 charities, and two of the findings are worth having in your head this month.

In 17 of the 24, Leadership and Governance scored above zero, which I take to mean the people at the top were mostly making fundraising easier. Fundraisers often tell me the board is the problem. In most of these charities, on this measure, it wasn’t.

In all 24, Capability Infrastructure scored below zero. That’s the Force that asks whether results rest on a few people or on a system that supports everyone: the tools, templates, data and written-down ways of working.

My reading, which I hold loosely, is that what was missing in most of these charities sat underneath the team, in the everyday kit they rely on. That’s good news for your budget conversation, because it’s something a finance director can put money towards once someone shows them where.

A page written for finance

When I built the report that comes out of the audit, I gave the finance director a page of their own. It sets out where the fundraising system is costing the charity value it can’t currently see, with the evidence behind each point.

It deliberately doesn’t put a pound figure on any of it, and that took some deciding. A number would look impressive, and it would also be a guess, and finance directors can spot a guess from across the room. Once they’ve spotted one they stop trusting the rest of the page. I’d rather hand them something accurate and modest that they can build on with their own figures, which they know far better than I do.

Evidence about the system gives the budget conversation somewhere new to go. “Here’s where we’re losing value, here’s what’s behind it, and here’s what it would take to fix” is a case a finance director can work with, and it moves the discussion on to the return on fundraising investment, which is where you want it.

Before the meeting

If I were walking into a budget meeting this month, I’d take the finance director for a coffee beforehand and ask what they’d need to see to say yes. I’d be clear that I meant the minimum they need, since a wish list won’t help either of you. Not many fundraising directors ask, in my experience, and the answer is often easier to meet than you’d think.

I’d also go in with at least one piece of evidence they can check for themselves. It needn’t be anything elaborate.

If you’d like that page in your hand

The Self Audit scores your own organisation across all eight Forces, with the evidence for every score and a page written for your finance director. Most people take 30 to 45 minutes over it, and it costs £495 plus VAT. A person at Fundraiser In The Room reads every report before you see it.

If you’re heading into budget season with a case you think will get pushed back, it’s worth having that page first.

Start the Self Audit


More insights

See your own system

Two minutes, sixteen questions. The free Stress Test shows where your fundraising system is under the most strain.